SPP Market Volatility: Deciphering Negative Pricing and Wind Curtailment Risks in 2026
The Southwest Power Pool (SPP), which manages the grid across 14 central states from North Dakota to parts of Texas, operates in the heart of "Wind Alley." Because so much wind generation has been built relative to the local population (demand) and the capacity of the interstate transmission lines, SPP frequently experiences negative wholesale prices. When the wind blows hard but overall power demand is low, oversupply pushes prices beneath $0/MWh. For corporate buyers invested in Virtual Power Purchase Agreements (VPPAs) in SPP, understanding the risk of "curtailment" (when a wind farm is forced to shut off by the grid operator) is critical to forecasting the financial performance of the asset.
Executive Impact (SPP Market)
- →The PTC Dynamic: Wind farms receive a federal Production Tax Credit (PTC) for every MWh they generate. This subsidy means a wind farm can offer its power into the SPP market at a negative price (e.g., -$15/MWh) and still turn a net profit over the course of the year.
- →Transmission Bottlenecks: Negative pricing is highly locational. It typically occurs at specific nodes where a large wind farm sits behind an inadequate, congested transmission line that cannot export the power to bigger cities.
- →VPPA Settle Risk: If a corporation\'s VPPA settles at an SPP node heavily prone to negative pricing, the corporation may owe large "settlement payments" to the developer during those negative intervals, flipping the VPPA from a financial hedge into a liability.
Navigating Curtailment Risk in Corporate Procurement
Curtailment is the ultimate risk for a renewable energy asset in SPP. When the grid simply cannot absorb another megawatt safely without overloading lines, the Independent System Operator (ISO) orders generators to dial back or stop producing entirely.
For a corporate buyer engaged in a VPPA to hit Scope 2 emissions reduction targets, curtailment is disastrous. A curtailed wind turbine generates exactly zero Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs) for the buyer to claim.
The "Economic Curtailment" Threshold
SPP contracts must carefully define negative price thresholds. Many modern VPPAs include an "economic curtailment" clause. This stipulates that if the real-time wholesale price dips below a certain negative number (say, -$20/MWh), the wind farm voluntarily curtails to avoid paying the grid.
Buyers must model exactly how many hours per year the specific node they are buying from is likely to hit that negative threshold, as it directly impacts both the financial settlement stack and the REC delivery volume.
Energy Storage as the Arbitrage Solution
To combat the "duck curve" of oversupply during windy nights and shortages during hot summer evenings, utility-scale Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) are critical to SPP\'s future.
- Asset Co-Location: Wind developers are increasingly co-locating battery storage at the point of interconnection. During negative pricing intervals, they charge the battery instead of fighting congestion on the transmission line.
- Discharge Profits: They then discharge that stored wind energy during the much higher-priced morning or evening ramp periods, effectively smoothing the volatility curve and ensuring their VPPA off-takers receive an optimized financial return.
Source: SPP Market Monitor Reports; Wind Integration Studies.
Looking to Structure a Commercial PPA?
Ensure your facility or sustainability plan accurately models node congestion and negative pricing risks in the SPP territory.